Yankees vs. Twins: Trust the Data | September 16, 2025

Kody Clemens - Twins

Yankees vs. Twins:  After being shut out 7-0 by the Twins on Monday, questions loom about their form and focus with the postseason looming. A team fighting for the AL East cannot afford to coast, yet New York has struggled to show urgency. Despite the frustration, there is reason for optimism. Their offense remains elite, loaded with hitters capable of punishing any pitcher.

Tonight presents a prime opportunity to bounce back, facing a right-hander who has struggled against lefties. For fans and bettors alike, this matchup demands attention as the Yankees look to reassert themselves.

For additional information on picks, props, moneylines, and more on today’s slate, take a look at our MLB Picks Page or our MLB Odds Page, here. 

4.8/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
55% Welcome Bonus w/ code BNBOL55
See our review »
Up to $250 in Free Bets + 100 Spins
$10 Cash Bonus w/ Code BNEWS
Fastest Payouts

Write Up Transparency

Be sure to follow me on X/Twitter @ColbyMBets to get my full card every day! Picks are always FREE.

Last Month: 42-86 (-10.83u)

Last Week: 5-24 (-6.78u)

ICE COLD. FADE ME.

Yankees vs. Twins Best Bets – September 16

Will the Yankees show any ounce of life tonight?

Check out BetOnline’s New No Strings Welcome Offer that gives new MLB players up to $250 in Free Bets and 100 Free Casino Spins with their first deposit. Find out more about this Promotion as well as lots of other Free Sportsbook Promos right here!

The lifeless Yankees were shut out on Monday night, falling 7-0 to the Twins. One would expect a team fighting for the AL East crown to at least put up a fight with 13 games left to play. Sadly, that was not the case. Even if the AL East title is out of reach, New York still needs to be firing on all cylinders heading into the postseason.

Yes, this is a Yankees fan rant. It is valid.

Trust the Data

Today, I am backing them again on the same prop as yesterday, but with even more data supporting the play. The Yankees offense ranks number one on Batters-Box. They boast nine elite-rated hitters in the default ratings. In the current season ratings, eight are elite and one is rated Great.

Over the last four weeks on the road, the Yankees lead in wRC+, wOBA, OPS, and ISO, while ranking second in hard-hit rate.

Zebby?

Tonight, they face Zebby Matthews. Admittedly, this is a name unfamiliar to many. The 25-year-old has been solid at home, posting a 3.56 ERA. Overall this season, however, he is allowing more than 5.5 hits and 2.5 runs per game, with opponents hitting over .280 against him.

Most of the Yankees’ elite hitters bat left-handed, which is a strong advantage against Matthews. In his last 60 matchups against lefties, he has struggled, posting a 7.50 ERA, 7.09 xERA, and 5.72 xFIP. Left-handed hitters are crushing him, carrying a .368 xBA, .645 xSLG, and .419 xwOBA in that span.

The Yankees may have looked lifeless in Monday’s loss, but all the signs point to a rebound tonight. Even if the AL East is slipping away, this team cannot enter the postseason cold. Their offense is elite, loaded with top-tier hitters capable of punishing any pitcher, and recent road splits show they are peaking at the right time.

Against Zebby Matthews, the matchup is glaringly in New York’s favor. Left-handed hitters, who make up the bulk of the lineup, have been tormenting him over his last 60 appearances. Statistically, he has struggled to limit damage, allowing high averages, slugging, and expected wOBA numbers. When you combine the Yankees’ recent dominance, the elite talent in their lineup, and the pitcher they are facing, this prop makes sense. Tonight presents an opportunity for New York to reassert themselves and send a statement before the postseason begins.

This lifelong Yankees fan is ready to throw in the towel if the team does not bounce back and deliver a strong performance tonight against this struggling Zebby. I still do not know what that name is…

Best Bet: Yankees First Five Team Total Over 2.5 Runs (+105) odds via BetOnline

Interested in More Content?

Get FREE Picks and Props Weekly

Sign up for
THE WEEKENDER NEWSLETTER

Follow me on X @ColbyMBets for all my picks and sports opinions. Follow Betting News on ‘X’ and Twitch and catch us on stream! Betting News is also on TikTok! Follow us for more picks and news every day!

In need of a sportsbook? Check out one of our favorites below among our best online sportsbooks and sign-up for a bonus!

1
Lucky Rebel Sportsbook logo 4.9/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
Up to $1,250 + 50 Free Slots Spins
See our review »
$1,250 Welcome Bonus
Bet Live on Your Favorite Sports
Earn More with Rebel Rewards!
2
4.8/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
55% Welcome Bonus w/ code BNBOL55
See our review »
Up to $250 in Free Bets + 100 Spins
$10 Cash Bonus w/ Code BNEWS
Fastest Payouts
3
4.7/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
100% up to $1000 Sign-Up Bonus
See our review »
Bonus Code: WELCOME1000
Monthly Cash Prizes
Vast Lines and Games Selection
4
4.6/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
55% Welcome Bonus w/ code BNSB55
See our review »
$250 in Free Bets with First Deposit
Same Game Parlays
Frequent Odds Boosters
5
4.5/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
50% Up to $750
See our review »
Best Prop Bets Selection
Boosted Odds on Parlays
One of the Oldest and Trusted Sites
6
4.4/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
125% Welcome Bonus
See our review »
Anonymous Crypto Betting
125% Welcome Bonus
Great Live Betting Selection
7
4.3/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
125% Deposit Bonus
See our review »
Fast & Easy Payouts
Best Deposit & Free Play Bonuses
Largest Selection of Sports & Games
8
4.2/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
125% Up to $3,125
See our review »
Best All Around Sportsbook
Most Competitive Odds
Sports, Casino, Poker & Racebook
9
4.1/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
100% Up to $1,000
See our review »
Free Contests for Real Money
Bet on Esports
Sportsbook, Casino & Racebook
10
4.0/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
Up to $1,000 Sign-Up Bonus
See our review »
100% of Your First Deposit
$10 Casino Chip
Limited Time Only

Check Out All of Our Betting Resources at Betting News

More Betting Stories