Presque Isle Downs Picks: Presque Isle Downs Masters (09/19/2025)

Horses leaving the starting gate at a race track

The racing action from Presque Isle Downs on Friday features the Presque Isle Downs Masters Stakes. @HandicappingT3 has all the Presque Isle Downs picks for the entire card!

Be sure to check out all the races and odds provided at the best horse racing betting sites.

Presque Isle Downs Full Card Analysis

Presque Isle Downs Picks: Presque Isle Downs Masters (09/19/2025)

Presque Isle Downs Picks: Presque Isle Downs Masters (09/19/2025)

Bet all of today’s selections with signup bonuses and promotions at BetOnline. Use promo code BNBOL55 at signup to get a 55% first deposit match!

BetOnline Racebook 5/5 Review Rating
Bonus & Benefits
Up to $250 in Free Bets + 100 Free Spins
See our review »
Received 50% of Your Initial Deposit Matched in Free Bet Credit
25+ Years Online
Fastest Payouts Guaranteed

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 1

Post Time: 5:00 PM ET; Allowance Optional Claiming $46k; 6 F All Weather; Field of 6 runners.

  • #2 SICKLE DANCE (3-1): Top pick. Looks good based on the 84 speed rating which is among the top in the group. Barn has been solid.
  • #5 FOXXY CLEOPATRA (9-5): Major Player. Trainer is having a great meet. Can run with these.
  • #6 YOUALMOSTHADME (7-2): Major Player. Previous success in similar race types.
  • #3 PRINCESS RUNAWAY (9-2): Major Player. Potential to get the pace of the race flow.

Selections: 2 – 5 – 6 – 3

The Plays

Win: #2 at 5-2

Exacta Box: 2,5,6

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 2

Post Time: 5:27 PM ET; Starter Optional Claiming $30k; 1 1/16 M All Weather; Field of 8 runners.

  • #3 BRILLIANT JOURNEY (7-2): Top pick. Top connections on the circuit with Montanez and Davis.
  • #4 ROYAL LUCK (5-2): Major Player. Should still be running strong in the closing stages.
  • #7 PRINCE OF AYRSHIRE (9-2): Major Player. Speed figs match up nicely. Previous success in similar race types.
  • #6 EXTRASEXYBIGDADDEE (6-1): Contender. Could be griding down the competition late. Trainer’s horses have been running.

Selections: 3 – 4 – 7 – 6

The Plays

Win: #3 at 3-1

Exacta: 3/ 4,7

Daily Double (races 2-3): #3,4,7 with #5

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 3

Post Time: 5:54 PM ET; Maiden Special Weight $40k; 6 F All Weather; Field of 8 runners.

Best Bet of the Card

  • #5 FREESTATE (7-2): Best bet of the card. Solid breeding for this spot. Rodriguez puts this one in with a chance. Bet today’s best bet with industry-leading rebates on BetOnline.
  • #8 LEFTNATEAWALKIN (3-1): Major Player. Balanced pace figures.
  • #2 BOSS’ DEED (4-1): Fringe Contender. Should find today’s group a bit softer than the last race. Previous success in similar race types.

Selections: 5 – 8 – 2

The Plays

Win: #5 at 1-1

Exacta: 5/ 8,2

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 4

Post Time: 6:21 PM ET; Starter Optional Claiming $27k; 1 1/4 M All Weather; Field of 9 runners.

  • #6 I LUCKED OUT (2-1): Top pick. Barn has been solid. Race may setup for this runner.
  • #9 THE BEST DISTANCE (5-2): Major Player. Trainer is having a great meet. Demonstrated success under similar conditions.
  • #5 STARSHIP EMPIRE (9-2): Major Player. Previous success in similar race types. Morales puts this one in with a chance.
  • #2 GOOSE HUNTER (12-1): Major Player. Race conditions fit this one well. Ran at this level last out.

Selections: 6 – 9 – 5 – 2

The Plays

Win: #6 at 2-1

Exacta Box: 6,9,5

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 5

Post Time: 6:48 PM ET; Allowance Optional Claiming $44k; 6 1/2 F All Weather; Field of 7 runners.

  • #3 CERTAIN (4-1): Top pick. Love the heart this one shows in a fight. Proven competitor at this configuration.
  • #5 TODDCHERO (5-2): Major Player. Speed figures match this group well. Should still be running strong in the closing stages.
  • #7 DOWAGIAC CHIEF (4-1): Major Player. Previous success in similar race types. Barn has been sending out runners.
  • #4 ROCKET DRAGON (5-1): Major Player. Ran at this level last out. Could be griding down the competition late.

Selections: 3 – 5 – 7 – 4

The Plays

Win: #3 at 5-2

Exacta Box: 3,5,7

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 6

Post Time: 7:15 PM ET; Presque Isle Debutante Stakes $100k; 6 1/2 F All Weather; Field of 10 runners.

  • #2 SMOOCH UP (7-2): Top pick. Top connections on the circuit with Morales and Potts. Proven competitor at this configuration.
  • #5 THANK YOU AMY (8-1): Major Player. Balanced pace figures. Seems to be up against the right competition.
  • #10 KONTIKI (9-5): Major Player. Barn has been sending out runners. Previous success in similar race types.
  • #1 IN HER GLORY (10-1): Contender. Should still have enough if the reserves if there in the final furlong. Can compete from a speed figure standpoint.

Selections: 2 – 5 – 10 – 1

The Plays

Win: #2 at 3-1

Exacta: 2/ 5,10

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 7

Post Time: 7:42 PM ET; Fitz Dixon, Jr. Memorial Juvenile Stakes $100k; 6 1/2 F All Weather; Field of 10 runners.

  • #9 MO DODGY (3-1): Top pick. Shouldn’t have trouble getting the distance. Proven competitor at this configuration.
  • #4 A MILLION DREAMS (8-1): Major Player. Expected to maintain its energy reserves into the final stretch. Seems to be up against the right competition.
  • #8 MAX CAPACITY (9-5): Contender. Morales and Sillaman team up on this one.
  • #10 JES SEE ME (9-2): Contender. Race conditions fit this one well. May be getting a weaker field than last out.

Selections: 9 – 4 – 8 – 10

The Plays

Win: #9 at 5-2

Exacta: 9/ 4,8

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 8

Post Time: 8:09 PM ET; Presque Isle Mile Stakes $150k; 1 1/16 M All Weather; Field of 13 runners.

  • #10 ENCINO (5-2): Prime Win Player. Comes in with solid form. Race sets up perfectly.
  • #9 TAPIT SHOES (7-2): Contender. Stamina to be in the mix late. Potentially cycling to a top performance.
  • #6 SKYRO (20-1): Fringe Contender. This one’s a fighter in the late stages. Barn has been sending out runners.
  • #2 THE WINE STEWARD (5-1): Underneath. Recent races are solid. Trainer’s horses have been running.

Selections: 10 – 9 – 6 – 2

The Plays

Win: #10 at 3-2

Exacta: 10/ 9,2

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 9

Post Time: 8:36 PM ET; Presque Isle Downs Masters Stakes $300k; 6 1/2 F All Weather; Field of 13 runners.

Longshot Play of the Day

Longshot Play of the Day

  • #3 ELYSIAN FIELD (6-1): Longshot play of the day. Love the heart this one shows in a fight. Barn has been solid. Bet today’s live longshot on MyBookie.
  • #9 STORMCAST (7-2): Major Player. Seems to be up against the right competition. Looks fast enough off previous efforts.
  • #6 PANDORA’S GIFT (5-1): Major Player. Hard to argue with the recent races. Speed figs match up nicely.
  • #2 TICKER TAPE HOME (10-1): Major Player. Expect this one to be able to carry the distance. Can compete from a speed figure standpoint.

Selections: 3 – 9 – 6 – 2

The Plays

Win: #3 at 5-1

Trifecta: 3/ 9,6/ 2,6,9

Presque Isle Downs Picks – Race 10

Post Time: 9:03 PM ET; Allowance $42k; 6 1/2 F All Weather; Field of 12 runners.

  • #12 MUSICAL MAESTRO (20-1): Top pick. Prat and Maker team up on this one. Love the heart this one shows in a fight.
  • #9 SCHNITTKER (12-1): Major Player. Demonstrated success under similar conditions. Seems to be up against the right competition.
  • #7 THOUGHTTHATCOUNTS (5-2): Major Player. Could jump up in the figures and be dangerous. Previous success in similar race types.
  • #6 GOLDENTOWN (7-2): Major Player. Competitive numbers early and late.

Selections: 12 – 9 – 7 – 6

The Plays

Win: #12 at 5-1

Trifecta: 12/ 9,7/ 6,7,9

Betting News Horse Racing Coverage

Don’t miss all the horse racing action covered by Betting News each and every week. Coverage includes free handicapping tools, comprehensive guides, and in-depth analysis of the week’s biggest cards. Check out our full card analysis for this week’s upcoming big races.

Friday Analysis

  • Presque Isle Downs Picks featuring the Grade 2 Presque Isle Downs Masters Stakes

Saturday Analysis